Deciding who should initiate divorce proceedings in India is a crucial strategic consideration. While the spouse who files first may gain some control over timing and jurisdiction, it doesn’t guarantee a significantly better outcome. This guide explores the advantages and disadvantages of filing first, helping you make an informed decision.
Potential Benefits of Filing First
Filing for divorce first can offer certain strategic advantages:
-
Control the Timeline: The spouse who files can decide when to start the legal process. This can prevent being caught off guard by the other spouse filing first.
-
Choose the Jurisdiction: If you and your spouse live in different states, filing first allows you to choose where the divorce will be filed. This can be advantageous if certain states have laws more favorable to your situation.
-
Make Preparations: Filing first provides time to gather financial records, open separate accounts, find a place to live, and prepare for single life. It allows you to take necessary steps without being rushed.
-
Asset Protection: Sadly, some spouses try to hide assets. Filing first may prevent your spouse from transferring property or money to conceal it.
-
Present Your Case First: The filer, or “plaintiff,” presents their side of the case first. They also get the opportunity to respond last to the other spouse’s arguments. This can provide a slight legal advantage.
Potential Disadvantages of Filing First
Filing first can also have potential drawbacks:
-
Reveal Your Position: As the filer, you must state your demands in the divorce petition. This reveals your intentions before negotiations begin.
-
Incur Higher Costs: The filer pays to serve the divorce papers to their spouse. The other spouse can simply mail their response, saving on expenses.
-
Appear Aggressive: Filing first might be perceived as aggressive, potentially leading to a more contentious divorce.
-
Lose the Moral High Ground: Societal norms often favor the spouse who appears reasonable and willing to compromise. Filing first may cede this perceived moral advantage.
Other Key Factors to Consider
Several other factors should influence your decision:
-
Child Custody: Custody is determined by the child’s best interests, not the filing order. However, filing first allows more time to establish a stable living situation, which may help in custody disputes.
-
No Statistical Advantage: The outcome depends more on negotiation and compromise, rather than who files first.
-
Consult a Lawyer: Understanding how local laws and judges view filing first is crucial. Perceptions vary by state and city.
-
Specific Circumstances: Weigh the pros and cons against your unique situation. If you recently moved, filing first to choose the jurisdiction might be important.
-
Focus on Amicable Resolution: Prioritize mediation and negotiation. Avoid seeing divorce as a battle that needs a strategic advantage.
Who Should File First: The Verdict
Filing first provides certain advantages, but it’s not a decisive factor for the final outcome. The focus should be on fairness, compromise, and compassion.